Reference note · Comparative studies
Who supervises whom? Supervisory architecture compared
A comparative map of the principal financial supervisory authorities in Spain, Belgium and the European Union, with comparative references to France, Germany and the United Kingdom.
- Published:
- Last reviewed:
§ 1Spain, Belgium and the European Union
Spain separates securities supervision (CNMV) from banking supervision (Banco de España, which also supervises the conduct of credit institutions towards their clients); insurance and pension funds are supervised by the Dirección General de Seguros y Fondos de Pensiones (DGSFP), part of the Ministry of Economy.
Belgium has followed a twin-peaks model since 2011: the National Bank of Belgium is responsible for the prudential supervision of credit institutions, insurance undertakings and other financial institutions, and the FSMA for the supervision of financial markets and of conduct towards clients, including the conduct rules applicable to investment services and insurance distribution.
Within the euro area, the European Central Bank carries out the prudential supervision of significant credit institutions directly within the Single Supervisory Mechanism, under Council Regulation (EU) No 1024/2013; national authorities supervise less significant institutions under the ECB’s oversight, and the ECB decides on the authorisation of all credit institutions. Conduct supervision, consumer protection and anti-money-laundering supervision are not ECB tasks and remain national.
The European Banking Authority and the European Securities and Markets Authority contribute to common rules and supervisory convergence, notably through technical standards and guidelines; they do not, as a rule, replace national supervisors in the day-to-day supervision of individual firms. ESMA nevertheless supervises certain entities directly, such as credit rating agencies and trade repositories. Insurance supervision is coordinated at EU level by EIOPA.
§ 2France and Germany
France separates market supervision (AMF) from prudential supervision of banking and insurance (ACPR); the ACPR is also responsible for the protection of the clients of the banks and insurers it supervises. Germany concentrates banking, insurance and securities supervision in BaFin, which cooperates with the Deutsche Bundesbank in banking supervision.
The same labels therefore do not correspond to identical competences: a “banking supervisor” may or may not also be responsible for client protection, depending on the jurisdiction.
§ 3United Kingdom and international standards
The United Kingdom separates conduct supervision (FCA) from prudential supervision (PRA, within the Bank of England), outside the EU framework. At international level, bodies such as the Basel Committee and IOSCO set standards that are not binding in themselves; they acquire legal force only when implemented in EU or national law.
Institutional architecture determines who may act, but not, by itself, who is liable. That question is addressed in the note on supervision and civil liability.
Sources and references
- [1]FSMA — Financial Services and Markets Authority(opens in a new window)Supervisory authority
- [2]National Bank of Belgium (NBB / BNB)(opens in a new window)Supervisory authority
- [3]Council Regulation (EU) No 1024/2013 (SSM Regulation)(opens in a new window)EU law
- [4]AMF — Autorité des marchés financiers(opens in a new window)Supervisory authority
- [5]ACPR — Autorité de contrôle prudentiel et de résolution(opens in a new window)Supervisory authority
- [6]BaFin — Bundesanstalt für Finanzdienstleistungsaufsicht(opens in a new window)Supervisory authority
- [7]Deutsche Bundesbank(opens in a new window)Supervisory authority
- [8]CNMV — Comisión Nacional del Mercado de Valores(opens in a new window)Supervisory authority
- [9]Banco de España(opens in a new window)Supervisory authority
- [10]DGSFP — Dirección General de Seguros y Fondos de Pensiones(opens in a new window)Supervisory authority
- [11]Regulation (EU) No 1093/2010 (EBA Regulation)(opens in a new window)EU law
- [12]Regulation (EU) No 1095/2010 (ESMA Regulation)(opens in a new window)EU law
- [13]EIOPA — European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority(opens in a new window)Supervisory authority
- [14]Financial Conduct Authority (FCA)(opens in a new window)Supervisory authority
- [15]Prudential Regulation Authority (Bank of England)(opens in a new window)Supervisory authority
- [16]Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BIS)(opens in a new window)International standard-setter (non-binding)
- [17]IOSCO — International Organization of Securities Commissions(opens in a new window)International standard-setter (non-binding)
This content is general legal information. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer–client relationship.
Related content
Legal concepts and terminology
Supervision is not compensation: supervisory duties and civil liability
Why a supervisory failure does not automatically give an individual a right to compensation — and why the question nevertheless remains a legal one.
Financial Regulation & Supervision · Financial Liability
Published Official sources: 5
Legal concepts and terminology
Causation and loss of a chance in financial disputes
Why the causal link is often the decisive question in investment and banking claims, and why loss of a chance is not a universal concept.
Financial Liability · Investor Protection
Published Official sources: 8
Legal concepts and terminology
Suitability and appropriateness under MiFID II
Two distinct assessments with distinct functions: what MiFID II requires, and why the distinction matters in an investment dispute.
Investor Protection · Financial Liability
Published Official sources: 9