Reference note · Legal concepts and terminology
Causation and loss of a chance in financial disputes
Why the causal link is often the decisive question in investment and banking claims, and why loss of a chance is not a universal concept.
- Published:
- Last reviewed:
§ 1The causal question
In many financial disputes, a breach of duty can be shown but its consequence cannot be established with certainty. Would the investor have chosen a different product if correctly informed? Would the borrower have obtained better terms elsewhere? The answer is hypothetical by nature.
Three questions must be kept apart. Causation asks whether the fault was a necessary condition of the harm. Damage asks what was lost: an actual loss (for example, the capital lost on an investment that would not otherwise have been made) or a lost chance of a favourable outcome. Quantification asks how that loss is measured. The answers depend on the applicable law, and EU financial legislation does not harmonise them: as a rule, it leaves damage and causation to national law.
§ 2Belgium
Book 6 of the Civil Code on extra-contractual liability (Law of 7 February 2024) entered into force on 1 January 2025. Under its transitional provision (Article 44 of that Law), it applies to facts giving rise to liability that occurred after that date; earlier facts, including their future effects, remain governed by the former Articles 1382 and following of the Civil Code.
Article 6.18 § 1 retains the necessary-condition test: a fact is the cause of damage if it is a necessary condition of that damage. Article 6.22 addresses uncertainty as to whether a fault was causal: where that uncertainty cannot be resolved, it provides for partial compensation in proportion to the probability that the fault caused the damage. This codifies a form of compensation for loss of a chance; its conditions and its relationship with the earlier case law of the Court of Cassation call for careful analysis. Only certain damage is compensable (Article 6.25), and the principle is full compensation (Article 6.30).
Contractual claims, which are frequent between banks and clients, are governed by Book 5 of the Civil Code (Law of 28 April 2022, in force since 1 January 2023 for legal acts and facts occurring after that date): the creditor is entitled to full compensation (Article 5.86), limited in principle to damage foreseeable when the contract was concluded (Article 5.87).
§ 3France
In French law, loss of a chance (perte de chance) is a judge-made concept based on the general rules of civil liability — Articles 1231-1 to 1231-4 of the Civil Code for contractual liability, under which damages cover only the immediate and direct consequence of the non-performance, and Article 1240 for extra-contractual liability — not on the Monetary and Financial Code. The Monetary and Financial Code defines duties of investment service providers; the consequences of their breach are assessed under civil-law rules.
The Cour de cassation characterises a compensable loss of a chance as the present and certain disappearance of a favourable eventuality (Assemblée plénière, 27 June 2025, No 22-21.146, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2025:AP00682). Compensation must be measured by the chance lost and cannot equal the advantage the chance would have procured had it materialised (1st Civil Chamber, 9 April 2002, No 00-13.314). In banking disputes, the Commercial Chamber has held that the damage resulting from a credit institution’s breach of its duty to warn consists in the loss of a chance not to contract (20 October 2009, No 08-20.274).
§ 4Quantification and comparison
Where a loss of a chance is recognised, it is often expressed as a fraction of the final loss reflecting the probability that the favourable outcome would have occurred. That fraction is not a fixed or automatic percentage: it results from the court’s assessment of the facts of each case, and it presupposes that the conditions for compensating a lost chance are met under the applicable law. Where the causal link with the whole loss is established, the whole loss is compensated; where no real chance was lost, nothing is.
Other systems approach similar situations primarily through the rules on causation, the standard of proof and the judicial estimation of damage. In English law, for example, the claimant must generally prove on the balance of probabilities what they would have done themselves, while what third parties would have done may be assessed as a lost chance (Perry v Raleys Solicitors [2019] UKSC 5). The term “loss of a chance” must therefore not be transposed mechanically from one jurisdiction to another: its existence, conditions and scope depend on the applicable law.
§ 5Evidence
Because the causal analysis depends on what would have happened, contemporaneous documents — information provided, client profiles, recordings and correspondence — are often decisive. Identifying which records exist, and who holds them, is an early step in any assessment.
Sources and references
- [1]Belgium — Law of 7 February 2024 inserting Book 6 “Extra-contractual liability” into the Civil Code (Articles 6.18, 6.22, 6.25, 6.30; transitional rule: Article 44)(opens in a new window)National law
- [2]Belgium — Law of 28 April 2022 inserting Book 5 “Obligations” into the Civil Code (Articles 5.86 and 5.87; transitional rule: Article 64)(opens in a new window)National law
- [3]France — Code civil, Article 1231-4(opens in a new window)National law
- [4]France — Code civil, Article 1240(opens in a new window)National law
- [5]Cour de cassation, Assemblée plénière, 27 June 2025, No 22-21.146, ECLI:FR:CCASS:2025:AP00682(opens in a new window)Case law
- [6]Cour de cassation, 1st Civil Chamber, 9 April 2002, No 00-13.314(opens in a new window)Case law
- [7]Cour de cassation, Commercial Chamber, 20 October 2009, No 08-20.274(opens in a new window)Case law
- [8]UK Supreme Court, Perry v Raleys Solicitors [2019] UKSC 5(opens in a new window)Case law
This content is general legal information. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer–client relationship.
Related content
Legal concepts and terminology
Suitability and appropriateness under MiFID II
Two distinct assessments with distinct functions: what MiFID II requires, and why the distinction matters in an investment dispute.
Investor Protection · Financial Liability
Published Official sources: 9
Legal concepts and terminology
Cross-border financial disputes: jurisdiction and applicable law
Which courts may hear a cross-border financial dispute, and which law governs it — the EU framework and its limits.
Financial Liability · Banking Disputes · Investor Protection
Published Official sources: 13
Legal concepts and terminology
Unauthorised payment transactions under PSD2
How the second Payment Services Directive allocates the risk of unauthorised transactions between payment service provider and payer.
Banking Disputes
Published Official sources: 9