Skip to content

Financial Law · II

Banking Disputes

Contracts, credit, payments and the duties of banks towards their clients.

Banking relationships are contractual relationships shaped by mandatory rules on credit, payment services and consumer protection. Disputes often turn on the content of the contract, the bank’s duty of care and the allocation of risk.

Scope

  1. 01Banking contracts and contractual liability
  2. 02Credit and lending disputes
  3. 03Payment services and unauthorised transactions
  4. 04Bank duties of care
  5. 05Financial information obligations
  6. 06Banking complaints and litigation
  7. 07Cross-border banking relationships
  8. 08Enforcement and jurisdiction

Legal frameworks

Spanish law, Belgian law and the EU law that applies to both, followed by the comparative questions that arise. Where EU rules are harmonised, national differences are not presumed.

ESSpain
PSD2 was transposed by Real Decreto-ley 19/2018 of 23 November 2018 on payment services; Articles 43 to 46 govern unauthorised transactions. Banking contracts are governed by the Código Civil and by consumer-protection legislation. Complaints may be brought before the complaints service of the Banco de España.
BEBelgium
Payment services and consumer credit are governed by Book VII of the Code of Economic Law, into which PSD2 was transposed by the Law of 19 July 2018. Banking contracts are governed by the Civil Code. Out-of-court complaints may be brought before Ombudsfin.
EUEuropean Union
PSD2 (Directive (EU) 2015/2366) harmonises the rules on unauthorised payment transactions. Consumer and mortgage credit are governed by EU directives transposed into national law. In cross-border cases, Brussels I bis, Rome I and Rome II determine jurisdiction and applicable law.
Comparative questions
Where the EU rules are harmonised, as they largely are for unauthorised payment transactions, national differences lie mainly in the options left to Member States, in procedure and evidence, and in the out-of-court routes available.

Questions the analysis asks

  • Which contract governs the relationship, and which mandatory rules apply regardless of its terms?
  • Was a payment transaction authorised, and who bears the burden of proving it?
  • Which information and warning duties did the bank have?
  • Which forum is competent, and where can a decision be enforced?

Reference notes in this area

Legal concepts and terminology

Unauthorised payment transactions under PSD2

How the second Payment Services Directive allocates the risk of unauthorised transactions between payment service provider and payer.

Banking Disputes

Published Official sources: 9

Legal concepts and terminology

Cross-border financial disputes: jurisdiction and applicable law

Which courts may hear a cross-border financial dispute, and which law governs it — the EU framework and its limits.

Financial Liability · Banking Disputes · Investor Protection

Published Official sources: 13