Skip to content

Reference note · Legal concepts and terminology

Unauthorised payment transactions under PSD2

How the second Payment Services Directive allocates the risk of unauthorised transactions between payment service provider and payer.

Published:
Last reviewed:

§ 1The basic allocation

Directive (EU) 2015/2366 (PSD2) contains harmonised rules on the rights and obligations of payment service users and providers. A payment transaction is authorised only if the payer has given consent (Article 64). Where a transaction was not authorised, Article 73(1) provides that the payer’s payment service provider must refund the amount immediately, and in any event no later than by the end of the following business day after noting or being notified of the transaction, and restore the debited account to the state it would have been in had the transaction not taken place. The only exception is where the provider has reasonable grounds for suspecting fraud and communicates those grounds to the relevant national authority in writing.

The refund is conditional on notification. Under Article 71(1), the payment service user must notify the provider without undue delay on becoming aware of the unauthorised transaction, and no later than 13 months after the debit date; that time limit does not apply where the provider failed to provide or make available the required information on the transaction. In Case C-337/20 CRCAM Alpes-Provence (judgment of 2 September 2021, ECLI:EU:C:2021:671), the Court of Justice held, under the predecessor Directive 2007/64/EC, that a user who did not notify within that period cannot rely on another national liability regime to obtain the same result. Its application to PSD2 is by analogy.

§ 2The payer’s share of the loss

Article 74(1) provides that the payer may be obliged to bear losses relating to an unauthorised transaction resulting from a lost or stolen payment instrument, or from its misappropriation, up to a maximum of EUR 50. The payer bears no such loss where the loss, theft or misappropriation was not detectable to the payer before the payment (unless the payer acted fraudulently), or where the loss was caused by acts or omissions of an employee, agent or branch of the provider or of an entity to which its activities were outsourced. Member States may reduce the payer’s liability where the payer has neither acted fraudulently nor intentionally failed to meet its obligations.

The payer bears all losses where it acted fraudulently or failed, intentionally or with gross negligence, to fulfil the obligations set out in Article 69 — such as using the instrument in accordance with its terms, keeping personalised security credentials safe and notifying the provider without undue delay of loss, theft, misappropriation or unauthorised use. After that notification, the payer bears no further financial consequences except in case of fraud (Article 74(3)).

Gross negligence does not suspend the refund obligation. In Case C-70/25 PKO BP (judgment of 15 October 2026), the Court of Justice held that a provider cannot refuse the immediate refund under Article 73(1) on the ground that the payer made the transaction possible through gross negligence; the allocation of the loss under Article 74(1) is a separate question.

§ 3Strong customer authentication

Article 97 requires providers to apply strong customer authentication when the payer accesses a payment account online, initiates an electronic payment transaction or carries out an action through a remote channel that may imply a risk of fraud. The technical standards are set out in Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2018/389, applicable since 14 September 2019. Under Article 74(2), where the payer’s provider does not require strong customer authentication, the payer does not bear any financial losses unless it acted fraudulently.

§ 4Evidence

Under Article 72(1), where a payment service user denies having authorised a transaction, it is for the payment service provider to prove that the transaction was authenticated, accurately recorded, entered in the accounts and not affected by a technical breakdown. Under Article 72(2), the use of a payment instrument recorded by the provider is not in itself necessarily sufficient to prove that the payer authorised the transaction or acted fraudulently or with gross negligence; the provider must provide supporting evidence of fraud or gross negligence.

Whether conduct amounts to gross negligence is assessed on the facts and under the national law transposing the Directive.

§ 5National implementation: Spain and Belgium

In Spain, PSD2 was transposed by Real Decreto-ley 19/2018 of 23 November 2018 on payment services. Articles 43 to 46 correspond to Articles 71 to 74 of the Directive: notification within 13 months (Article 43), proof of authentication (Article 44), the immediate refund (Article 45) and the payer’s liability, including the EUR 50 limit (Article 46). Where a provider relies on a reasonable suspicion of fraud to withhold the immediate refund, Article 45 requires it to communicate its grounds in writing to the Banco de España. Complaints may be brought before the complaints service of the Banco de España.

In Belgium, PSD2 was transposed into Book VII of the Code of Economic Law by the Law of 19 July 2018; Articles VII.41 to VII.44 correspond to Articles 71 to 74 of the Directive, including the EUR 50 limit. Out-of-court complaints may be brought before Ombudsfin.

§ 6A framework under review

The Commission proposed in 2023 to replace PSD2 with a third Payment Services Directive and a Payment Services Regulation, with new rules on impersonation fraud. The European Parliament and the Council reached a provisional agreement on 27 November 2025. At the date of review (18 November 2026), the texts had not been published in the Official Journal; they are prospective and PSD2, as transposed, remains the applicable framework. Separately, Regulation (EU) 2024/886 on instant credit transfers has required providers in the euro area to offer verification of the payee since 9 October 2025.

Before relying on any provision, its current version and the applicable transitional rules must be checked in the Official Journal of the European Union and in the national transposing law.

This content is general legal information. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer–client relationship.

All insights

Legal concepts and terminology

Causation and loss of a chance in financial disputes

Why the causal link is often the decisive question in investment and banking claims, and why loss of a chance is not a universal concept.

Financial Liability · Investor Protection

Published Official sources: 8

Legal concepts and terminology

Suitability and appropriateness under MiFID II

Two distinct assessments with distinct functions: what MiFID II requires, and why the distinction matters in an investment dispute.

Investor Protection · Financial Liability

Published Official sources: 9

Legal concepts and terminology

Cross-border financial disputes: jurisdiction and applicable law

Which courts may hear a cross-border financial dispute, and which law governs it — the EU framework and its limits.

Financial Liability · Banking Disputes · Investor Protection

Published Official sources: 13