Reference note · Legal concepts and terminology
Cross-border financial disputes: jurisdiction and applicable law
Which courts may hear a cross-border financial dispute, and which law governs it — the EU framework and its limits.
- Published:
- Last reviewed:
§ 1Two distinct questions
In a cross-border financial dispute, the question of which courts have jurisdiction is distinct from the question of which law applies. A court may have jurisdiction and yet apply a foreign law. Within the European Union, the first question is governed principally by Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012 (Brussels I bis), and the second by Regulation (EC) No 593/2008 (Rome I) for contractual obligations and Regulation (EC) No 864/2007 (Rome II) for non-contractual obligations.
Under Brussels I bis, a defendant domiciled in a Member State may in principle be sued there (Article 4). Alternative grounds include the place of performance of a contractual obligation (Article 7(1)), the place where the harmful event occurred (Article 7(2)) and the place of a branch for disputes arising from its operations (Article 7(5)). Where a defendant is not domiciled in a Member State, jurisdiction is in principle determined by national law (Article 6), subject to the consumer and exclusive-jurisdiction rules. For investors who suffered purely financial loss, the Court of Justice has located the place of damage restrictively, depending on the circumstances (Case C-375/13 Kolassa, 28 January 2015; Case C-304/17 Löber, 12 September 2018; Case C-709/19 VEB, 12 May 2021).
§ 2Choice of court and choice of law
Parties may agree on the competent court (Article 25 of Brussels I bis) and choose the law applicable to their contract (Article 3 of Rome I). In non-contractual matters, a choice of law made before the event giving rise to the damage is permitted only between parties pursuing a commercial activity (Article 14 of Rome II); failing a choice, the law of the country where the damage occurs applies in principle (Article 4).
§ 3Consumers
Both Brussels I bis and Rome I contain protective rules for consumer contracts. Where Articles 17 to 19 of Brussels I bis apply — in particular where the professional directs its activities to the consumer’s Member State — the consumer may sue in the courts of their own domicile, may be sued only there, and a choice-of-court clause concluded before the dispute is effective only within narrow limits. Under Article 6 of Rome I, a choice of law cannot deprive the consumer of the protection of the mandatory rules of the law of their habitual residence.
These rules do not apply automatically to every investor. Consumer status depends on whether the contract was concluded for a purpose outside the person’s trade or profession; the Court of Justice has held that a person trading contracts for difference may be a consumer, and that the value of the transactions, the risks involved and the person’s knowledge are in principle irrelevant (Case C-208/18 Petruchová, 3 October 2019; Case C-500/18 Reliantco, 2 April 2020). Rome I moreover excludes from its consumer rule rights and obligations constituting a financial instrument and the terms of issues and offers of transferable securities (Article 6(4)(d)), as well as contracts concluded within multilateral trading systems (Article 6(4)(e)). Whether an investor or borrower qualifies as a consumer, and whether the contract falls within those rules, requires analysis of the facts.
§ 4Collective claims and the United Kingdom
Directive (EU) 2020/1828 requires Member States to provide representative actions for the protection of the collective interests of consumers, including in financial services, from 25 June 2023; the national procedures implementing it differ. The Directive does not alter the rules of private international law (Article 2(3)).
The United Kingdom is no longer bound by Brussels I bis for proceedings instituted after the end of the transition period on 31 December 2020 (Article 67 of the Withdrawal Agreement), and the European Union has not consented to its accession to the 2007 Lugano Convention. Jurisdiction and recognition of judgments in relations with the United Kingdom therefore depend on national law and on the Hague Conventions of 2005 on Choice of Court Agreements and of 2019 on Judgments (the latter in force for the United Kingdom since 1 July 2025). Rome I and Rome II continue to apply in the United Kingdom as domestic law in amended form.
Sources and references
- [1]Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012 (Brussels I bis)(opens in a new window)EU law
- [2]Regulation (EC) No 593/2008 (Rome I)(opens in a new window)EU law
- [3]Regulation (EC) No 864/2007 (Rome II)(opens in a new window)EU law
- [4]CJEU, Case C-375/13, Kolassa v Barclays Bank plc, judgment of 28 January 2015, ECLI:EU:C:2015:37(opens in a new window)Case law
- [5]CJEU, Case C-304/17, Löber v Barclays Bank plc, judgment of 12 September 2018(opens in a new window)Case law
- [6]CJEU, Case C-709/19, Vereniging van Effectenbezitters v BP plc, judgment of 12 May 2021(opens in a new window)Case law
- [7]CJEU, Case C-208/18, Petruchová v FIBO Group Holdings Ltd, judgment of 3 October 2019(opens in a new window)Case law
- [8]CJEU, Case C-500/18, AU v Reliantco Investments Ltd, judgment of 2 April 2020(opens in a new window)Case law
- [9]Directive (EU) 2020/1828 (Representative Actions)(opens in a new window)EU law
- [10]Agreement on the withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the European Union, Article 67(opens in a new window)EU law
- [11]European Commission, Communication COM(2021) 222 final on the UK application to accede to the 2007 Lugano Convention(opens in a new window)EU law
- [12]HCCH — Convention of 30 June 2005 on Choice of Court Agreements, status table(opens in a new window)International standard-setter (non-binding)
- [13]HCCH — Convention of 2 July 2019 on Judgments, status table(opens in a new window)International standard-setter (non-binding)
This content is general legal information. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer–client relationship.
Related content
Legal concepts and terminology
Causation and loss of a chance in financial disputes
Why the causal link is often the decisive question in investment and banking claims, and why loss of a chance is not a universal concept.
Financial Liability · Investor Protection
Published Official sources: 8
Legal concepts and terminology
Suitability and appropriateness under MiFID II
Two distinct assessments with distinct functions: what MiFID II requires, and why the distinction matters in an investment dispute.
Investor Protection · Financial Liability
Published Official sources: 9
Legal concepts and terminology
Unauthorised payment transactions under PSD2
How the second Payment Services Directive allocates the risk of unauthorised transactions between payment service provider and payer.
Banking Disputes
Published Official sources: 9