Skip to content

Financial Law · IV

Financial Liability

Civil liability of financial actors, causation, damages and evidence.

When financial duties are breached, accountability is ultimately a question of liability law: contractual and non-contractual responsibility, the causal link, the assessment of damage and the evidence that supports each of them.

Scope

  1. 01Civil liability of financial institutions
  2. 02Professional negligence
  3. 03Contractual and non-contractual liability
  4. 04Directors’ liability where relevant
  5. 05Causation
  6. 06Loss of a chance
  7. 07Financial damages
  8. 08Evidentiary challenges
  9. 09Collective or multi-party disputes
  10. 10International jurisdiction and applicable law

Legal frameworks

Spanish law, Belgian law and the EU law that applies to both, followed by the comparative questions that arise. Where EU rules are harmonised, national differences are not presumed.

ESSpain
Contractual liability is governed by Articles 1101 and following of the Código Civil, and non-contractual liability by Articles 1902 and following. A FINANTROPY analysis of Spanish law on causation and loss of a chance is in preparation.
BEBelgium
Non-contractual liability is governed by Book 6 of the Civil Code, which applies to facts occurring after 1 January 2025, and contractual liability by Book 5. Article 6.22 provides for proportional compensation where it remains uncertain whether a fault caused the damage.
EUEuropean Union
EU financial legislation generally leaves damage, causation and civil liability to national law, subject to the principles of equivalence and effectiveness. Brussels I bis, Rome I and Rome II determine jurisdiction and applicable law, and Directive (EU) 2020/1828 requires representative actions for consumers.
Comparative questions
Concepts such as loss of a chance do not have the same meaning or scope in every legal system. The note on causation compares Belgian and French law and refers to English law.

Questions the analysis asks

  • Is the claim contractual, non-contractual, or can both be invoked under the applicable law?
  • What standard of care applied to the financial professional?
  • How is the damage measured, and at what date?
  • Is a collective or multi-party procedure available, and is it appropriate?

Reference notes in this area

Legal concepts and terminology

Suitability and appropriateness under MiFID II

Two distinct assessments with distinct functions: what MiFID II requires, and why the distinction matters in an investment dispute.

Investor Protection · Financial Liability

Published Official sources: 9

Legal concepts and terminology

Supervision is not compensation: supervisory duties and civil liability

Why a supervisory failure does not automatically give an individual a right to compensation — and why the question nevertheless remains a legal one.

Financial Regulation & Supervision · Financial Liability

Published Official sources: 5

Legal concepts and terminology

Causation and loss of a chance in financial disputes

Why the causal link is often the decisive question in investment and banking claims, and why loss of a chance is not a universal concept.

Financial Liability · Investor Protection

Published Official sources: 8

Legal concepts and terminology

Cross-border financial disputes: jurisdiction and applicable law

Which courts may hear a cross-border financial dispute, and which law governs it — the EU framework and its limits.

Financial Liability · Banking Disputes · Investor Protection

Published Official sources: 13